"Say it ain't so, Joe!"
Or, "When murdered people are like baby elephants, and other similarly appalling comparisons"
By Jeff Emanuel Posted in Academia | ESPN | Featured Stories | Special Features | Virginia Tech — Comments (17) / Email this page » / Leave a comment »
ESPN baseball analyst Joe Morgan made what is, in my opinion, an absolutely egregious faux pas while a guest on yesterday's edition of the Dan Patrick show on ESPN Radio. Asked what he thought about the Virginia Tech massacre, Morgan said:
I was sitting there yesterday, and to be honest with you, I was equating it a little bit to the Imus thing; here are kids going to school, not bothering anybody, trying to, you know, make something of themselves, trying to be better, and this is what they're subjected to. I mean, the kids who are still at that school, how are they going to handle this?
He went on to lament that, since this did not take place during football or basketball season, then "everyone that's involved, that was touched by it directly, they pretty much have to deal with it by themselves."
Are you kidding, Joe?
Read on . . .
Of course, it didn't stop there - Senator and Presidential candidate Barack Obama concurred, issuing a statement in which he directly compared Monday’s "physical violence" at Virginia Tech to the "verbal violence" of the since-fired radio shock jock.
Nikki Giovanni, a poet and University Distinguished Professor at Virginia Tech, said this in her speech at the school's remembrance ceremony yesterday:
We do not understand this tragedy. We know we did not deserve it but neither does a child in Africa dying of AIDS, but neither do the invisible children walking the night to avoid being captured by a rogue army. Neither does the baby elephant watching his community be devastated for ivory; neither does the Appalachian infant killed in the middle of the night in his crib in the home his father built with his own hands being run over by a boulder because the land was destabilized. No one deserves a tragedy.
What an insult these statements are to the victims of this act - comparing them to baby elephants, and equating the senseless loss of life to the offending of sensibilities.
We continue to grieve for those lost, and those left behind, as a result of this unspeakable tragedy - and will not dishonor their experiences, or their memories, by drawing such appallingly pathetic comparisons.
« The City: A New Journal of Faith, Culture, and Politics — Comments (3) | Can government legislate "Intellectual Diversity" (without becoming the Thought Police)? — Comments (22) »
"Say it ain't so, Joe!" 17 Comments (0 topical, 17 editorial, 0 hidden) Post a comment »
Nikki Giovanni, a poet and University Distinguished Professor at Virginia Tech, said this in her speech at the school's remembrance ceremony yesterday:
We do not understand this tragedy. We know we did not deserve it but neither does a child in Africa dying of AIDS, but neither do the invisible children walking the night to avoid being captured by a rogue army. Neither does the baby elephant watching his community be devastated for ivory; neither does the Appalachian infant killed in the middle of the night in his crib in the home his father built with his own hands being run over by a boulder because the land was destabilized. No one deserves a tragedy.
This is the very definition of evil.
I don't know who this Nikki Giovanni is, but this is the most outrageous thing I've ever ready.
Has he/she been fired?????
Doubtful she is fired. I also suspect many of her fellow faculty members are more in agreement than disagreement with her views. I have no proof of this, but my experience in academia seems to point in that direction.
of the creative writing department at VT. What makes her idiotic speech all the more incredibly offensive is that she had the killer, Cho, in her classes and knew him quite well. Well enough (by her account) to demand that he be removed from her class or she would resign.
In other words someone in a position of responsibility to the students completely ignores that responsibility yet has the gall to point out other "victims".
In general I've been impressed by what I've read of the faculty at VT, not surprising as they are mostly science and engineering. The Humanities are going to be more reliably idiotic. By the way, it seems there was a lot more to Cho's classroom behavior than bad writing. In one course the other students were so alarmed they refused to attend class with him,so he had to be taught one on one by the prof. This prof was so afraid that she worked out an alarm system with her assistant, so that if the prof used the name of a (dead) professor, that would be the signal for the assistant to call the police.
And so on. There's an implication that some of these teachers gave Cho good grades in hopes of getting him graduated and away from the school, where he would be someone else's problem. Yet I'm not surprised they're moralizing and pontificating about our violent society, etc.
roared the students into a Pro- VT frenzy. I doubt that they will fire her because she inspired those heartbroken students.
I didn't hear a word she said but they clearly loved her for whatever she said.
If she survives those words, Imus should demand an apology and his job back!
I think you are misreading her poem.
As a VT Alum I watched the entire convocation; while I didn't think it was the best poem ever, her point was not equating the magnitude or cause of the events.
Her point was that "life is not fair", "bad things happen to good people" (elephants?), BUT we will overcome because "WE ARE VIRGINIA TECH!". To that end, I thought it was appropriate. I was also pleased by the spontaneous student response at the end.
This is a horrible crime, commited by an individual who chose to continue down an evil path, but will not destroy the Hokie spirit.
Equating a masacare and Imus' comments is assinine, Nikki's speech was not.
I will also say that I was most impressed with Gov. Kaine's comments. I hope he applies his "I loathe..." comment to both sides of the gun control debate.
The PC invitation to cover religious bases annoyed me more than anything else.
want to become part of the "victimhood fraternity," even though the only thing they have in common with the real victims was their attendance at Virginia Tech.
"We will overcome because WE ARE VIRGINIA TECH?" What do "we" have to overcome? The families and roommates of the victims and others who were threatened need recovery, but somebody who simply was on the campus?
Harry Reid on Iraq: “I say we’ve lost. Let’s bring our boys home in, oh, say 18 months. In the meantime, no more funding for them.”
Every time any event like this happens, a whole lot of people seem to feel the need to unnecessarily make themselves a part of it by grasping at whatever connections they can find. I find it extremely distasteful.
---
Underlying most arguments against the free market is a lack of belief in freedom itself. - Milton Friedman
I've been waiting to hear SOMETHING of Obama's politics from some source. Up till today, all I knew about him was that he's (a) A democrat, (b) black (although there seems to be some contention on that matter), and (c) not quite as moon-barkingly crazy as what passes for black democrat leadership these days.
Well, I guess I'm not down to TWO salient details, because if he can't tell the difference between a body count and the ill-chosen words of an over-the-hill DJ trying to sound hip by uttering a phrase only black people are allowed to use, I guess I need to strike "c" off my list.
..., I'm not all that surprised.
Equating dealing with mass murder to having to cope with the ramblings of some irrelevant talk show host is beyond stupid.
Joe Morgan has always been an idiot, so I would expect something like this from him. He's a horrible announcer, is jealous of any player who is better than he was, and has way too high of an opinion of himself. How in the world is a guy murdering 32 people in any way similar to Don Imus describing women's basketball players as nappy headed hos? And its a shame this didn't happen during football season? Wow...
...was completely agreeing with him on that last point. While sports can help us heal, I have trouble with the inane idea that, without sports, there can be no healing.
a Doctor of Philosophy.
Harry Reid on Iraq: “I say we’ve lost. Let’s bring our boys home in, oh, say 18 months. In the meantime, no more funding for them.”
A frequently amusing baseball website that rips Morgan (and others in baseball media) for saying stupid things - www.firejoemorgan.com - also got on him over these comments. Typically they reserve their ire for things like his tendency to ignore statistics in favor of "grittiness" when judging a player's worth to his team, but they feel free to rip away over inane comments regarding the real world as well.
Fair warning: Profanity...


I seem to be thinking to myself a lot lately. How does the old saying go "actions speak louder than words"? So (according to Joe) a verbal miscue is the same as mass murder? I'm also tired (already) of people trying to figure out where society failed this murderer. How about this folks, he was an evil little buger and he committed a viscous act, end of story.